Daripada ‘Maya’ kepada ‘Nyata’: Kajian Identiti Nasional Sasterawan Mahua Lu Po-Yeh
Main Article Content
Abstract
The Chinese who migrated overseas initially brought with them their original culture and identity. Later generations of these early settlers, even though inheriting the original ‘Chinese’ culture and identity, have such an identity, which is in fact an ‘imagined’ (virtual) identity. It was because they had settled there for a long time and had never experienced life in Mainland China. Political turmoil and the international situation then stimulated virtual identities to transform into identities of the place they were born and live, which is more realistic. Lu Po-yeh (1923–1961), a Chinese writer who was born and raised in British Malaya, once considered his identity to be ‘Chinese’ but changed to a local Chinese identity by claiming himself to be a citizen of the Federation of Malaya. This article examines Lu Po-yeh’s shift in national identity, which began with his doubts about his own identity after facing a process of integration, adaptation, and change during his search for self-discovery. Lu Po-yeh had experienced many changes in his life and lived through several important eras, including the era of British colonialism, the Japanese Occupation of Malaya, and the era of Malaya’s struggle for independence. Such life experiences eventually enabled Lu Po-yeh to come to the realisation that his identity was as a Malayan Chinese. Thus, the writings and activities carried out by Lu Po-yeh were closely related to the atmosphere of development at that time. Through Lu Po-yeh’s literary writings and cultural activities, a change in the stance of national identity by his peers was clearly displayed. Lu Po-yeh’s life experiences through the different eras of Malayan history made an impact on the realisation of his true identity – from a vague and virtual ‘China’ identity to a clearer and more realistic ‘Malayan’ identity. Lu Po-yeh’s process of exploring national identity also illustrates the process of the changing stance of Chinese identity in Malaya in the 1950s, where the Chinese wanted to work together to develop a multi-ethnic society in a new and united nation.
Orang Cina yang berhijrah ke seberang laut pada mulanya membawa bersama budaya dan identiti asal mereka. Setelah mereka menetap lama di luar kawasan Tanah Besar China, generasi selepas mereka yang tidak pernah menjalani kehidupan di China sungguhpun mewarisi budaya dan identiti ‘China’ asal tetapi identiti sedemikian pada hakikatnya sekadar ‘identiti bayangan’ (maya) sahaja. Pergolakan politik dan situasi antarabangsa kemudian merangsang identiti maya berubah kepada identiti tempat kelahiran dan kehidupan mereka yang lebih realiti dan nyata. Lu Po-yeh (1923–1961), seorang sasterawan Cina yang dilahirkan dan dibesarkan di Tanah Melayu pernah menganggap identiti beliau sebagai ‘China’ tetapi berubah kepada identiti Cina tempatan dengan mendakwa dirinya sebagai rakyat Persekutuan Tanah Melayu. Artikel ini mengkaji perubahan identiti nasional Lu Po-yeh yang bermula dengan keraguannya dengan identiti sendiri setelah menghadapi proses kesepaduan, penyesuaian dan perubahan dalam perjalanan mencari identiti diri. Lu Po-yeh pernah mengalami banyak perubahan dalam kehidupannya dan melalui beberapa era yang penting iaitu zaman penjajahan British, pendudukan Jepun dan era perjuangan kemerdekaan Tanah Melayu sepanjang hayatnya. Pengalaman kehidupan sedemikian akhirnya membolehkan Lu Po-yeh mengenal pasti pendirian identitinya. Oleh yang demikian, penulisan dan kegiatan yang dijalankan oleh Lu Po-yeh berkait rapat dengan suasana perkembangan semasa pada zaman itu. Melalui penulisan sastera dan kegiatan budaya Lu Po-yeh, suatu perubahan pendirian identiti nasional oleh generasi sebayanya telah dipaparkan dengan jelas. Perkembangan sejarah dan pengalaman kehidupan Lu Po-yeh mengubah identiti nasional peringkat awalnya yang ‘kabur’ iaitu identiti ‘China’ (maya) kepada identiti yang ‘jelas’ iaitu identiti ‘Tanah Melayu’ (nyata). Proses penerokaan identiti nasional Lu Po-yeh turut menggambarkan proses perubahan pendirian identiti orang Cina di Tanah Melayu pada zaman 1950-an yang ingin berganding bahu demi membangunkan sebuah negara yang baharu dan bersatu padu dalam masyarakat yang pelbagai etnik.
Article Details

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
References
Albert, L. 1989. Malayan Union citizenship: Constitutional change and controversy in Malaya, 1942–1948. Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 20(2): 216–243. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022463400018105
Anderson, B. 2006. Imagined communities: Reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism, 131–140. New York, USA: Verso Books.
Carnell, F.G. 1952. Malayan citizenship legislation. International and Comparative Law Quarterly 1(4): 504–518. https://doi.org/10.1093/iclqaj/1.Pt4.504
Chen, R.F. 1929. Nanyang Huaqiao de Jiaoyu Tan 《南洋华侨的教育谈 》(Perbincangan tentang pendidikan diaspora Cina). In Huaqiao Jiaoyu Lunwen Ji《华侨教育论文集》(Koleksi tesis pendidikan diaspora China), 372. Guangdong: Bahagian Kebudayaan Nanyang National Chi Nan University.
Choi, K.K. 2007. Malaixiya Huaren Guojia Rentong Zhuanxiang 1950–1957 《马来西亚华人国家认同转 向1950–1957》(Perubahan identiti orang Cina Malaysia 1950–1957). In Xinma Huaren de RentongZhuanxiang 1945–1959 《新马华人国家认同的转向 1945–1959》(Perubahan identiti nasional orang Cina di Singapura dan Malaysia 1945–1959). Singapura: Youth Book Co.
Fang, J.Y. 2001. Dongnanya “Huaren Wenti” de Xingcheng yu Fazhan – Taiguo, Feilvbin, Malaixiya, Yindunixiya 《东南亚“华人问题”的形成与发展-泰国、菲律宾、马来西亚、印度尼西亚案例研究》(Faktor dan perkembangan isu orang Cina di Asia Tenggara – Kajian kes Thailand, Filipina, Malaysia, Indonesia), 13. Beijing: Shishi Publishing House.
Hu, C. Y. 2010. Kangzheng yu Tuoxie: Malai Xiya Huase dui Huazy Muyu Jiaoyu Zhengce Zhiding de Yingxiang 《抗争与妥协:马来西亚华社对华族母语教育政策制定的影响》, (Perjuangan dan kompromi: Pengaruh masyarakat Cina Malaysia terhadap penggubalan dasar pendidikan bahasa ibunda). PhD diss., 29–31. Jinan University.
Low, C.C. 2013. Isu dwikerakyatan dalam pembentukan kewarganegaraan Malaysia 1900–1965: 13–39. Pulau Pinang: Penerbit Universiti Sains Malaysia.
Lu, P. 1953. Shicheng Sanji 《狮城散记》(Catatan cebisan Singapura). Singapore: World Book Company.
. 1954. Malai Sanji 《马来散记》(Catatan cebisan Malaya). Singapore: World Book Company.
. 1958. Malaiya 《马来亚》(Malaya). Singapore: World Book Company.
. 2019. Malai Sanji 《马来散记》(Catatan cebisan Malaya). Edisi baru. Singapore: Chou Sing Chu Foundation.
Mak, L.F. 2012. Xuni Rentong: Zaoqi Malaiya Huaren de Aiguo Gequ 《虚拟认同:早期马来亚华人的爱国歌曲 》,(Identiti dan bayangan: Lagu patriotik etnik Cina di Malaya pada peringkat awal). Singapura: Chinese Heritage Centre.
Halbwachs, M. 2002. On collective memory, L.A. Coser (ed., trans.). Chicago, USA: The University Of Chicago Press.
Hara, F. 2003. Malayan Chinese and China: Conversion in identity consciousness, 1945–1957. Singapore: Singapore University Press.
Hogg, M.A. and D. Abrams. 2006. Social identifications: A social psychology of intergroup relations and group processes. Milton, UK: Routledge.
Kuhn, P.A. 2009. Chinese among others: Emigration in modern times. Maryland, USA: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc. https://doi.org/10.5771/9780742573246-239
Liua, S. Y. 2020. Lun Lu Bai Ye Malaisanji ji qi Xuji zhong de Shenfen Rentong 《论鲁白野《马来散记》及其续集中的身份认同与叙事策略》(Kajian identiti dan strategi naratif Lu Bai Ye dalam catatan Cebisan Melayu dan jilid sambungannya). Bachelor’s degree diss., Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman.
Persatuan Linguistik Malaysia. n.d. Pasangan Cina pencipta 17 kamus Melayu-Cina ini terima Anugerah Pencapaian SBC. https://plm.org.my/pasangan-cina-pencipta-17-kamus-melayu-cina-ini-terima-anugerah-pencapaian-sbc/
Shamsul, A.B. 2004. Text and collective memories: The construction of “Chinese” and “Chineseness” from the prespective of a Malay. In Ethnic relations and nation-building in Southeast Asia: The case of the ethnic Chinese, ed. L. Suryadinata, 109–144. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies–Yusof Ishak Institute.
Tan, C.B. 1997. Chinese identities in Malaysia. Asian Journal of Social Science 25(2): 103–116. https://doi.org/10.1163/030382497X00194
Teoh, K.H. 2016. Bianzhe Xu《编者序》(Prakata). In Weibeihua Wenyi Chuangzuo Zongji《威北华文艺创作总集》(Koleksi Sastera Wei Pe Hua). Petaling Jaya, Malaysia: Got One Publisher Sdn. Bhd.
Wang, G. 1970. Chinese politics in Malaya. The China Quaterly. 43: 1–30. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0305741000044726
Wang, H. 2014. Dongya de Zhanzheng zhi Kuang yu Guozu Wenti: Dui Riben, Zhongguo, Taiwan de Kaocha 《东亚的战争之框与国族问题:对日本、中国、台湾的考察》 (Kerangka perang di Asia Timur dan isu kewarganegaraan). In Zhanzheng yu Shehui: Lilun, Lishi yu Zhuti Jingyan 《战争与社会:理论、历史与主体经验》 (Perang dan masyarakat: Teori, sejarah dan pengalaman subjektif), 157–225. Taipei: Linking Publishing.
Wang, M.K. 2006. Huaxia Bianyuan – Lishi Jiyi yu Zuqun Rentong 《华夏边缘——历史记忆与族群认同》 (Sempadan Cina - Memori sejarah dan identiti etnik), 254. Beijing, China: Social Science Academic Press.
Wang, Y.W. 2015. Daoliu de Shihe: Wei Pe Hua Liuwang yu Feixu de Shuxie《倒流的诗河:威北华流亡与废墟的书写》(Sajak yang mengalir terbalik: Penulisan Wei Pe Hua dalam Pelarian dan Buangan). In Shidai, Dianlv, Bentuxing: Mahua Xiandaishi Lunshu《时代、典律、本土性:马华现代诗论述 》(Era, Canon dan Unsur Tempatan: Wacana Sajak Moden Mahua). Kampar, Malaysia: Institut Pengajian Cina, Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman.
Wei, P.H. 2016. Teoh Kian Hoon (ed.). Wei Pe Hua Wenyi Chuangzuo Zongji 《威北华文艺创作总集 》(Koleksi sastera hasil karya Wei Pe Hua). Petaling Jaya: Got One Publisher Sdn. Bhd.
Wu, Y.J. and H.M. Gu. 2018. Guojia Rentong Zhong de Lishi Jiyi Wenti《国家认同建构中的历史记忆问题》(Isu memori sejarah dalam pembinaan identiti nasional). Wenhua Yanjiu 《文化研究》(A Journal of Cultural Studies): 76–83.