Assessing the Role of Planning and Considerations in the Sustainability of BRT-PPP Projects: A South African Case
Main Article Content
Abstract
The development of bus rapid transit (BRT) systems is essential to African cities’ economic vitality through accessibility and expansion of urban mobility. Several studies have investigated the deployment of such transportation systems. However, the role of a delineated planning stage of BRTs has been given limited attention. This study examined the role of planning in ensuring the sustainable performance of BRT systems. A qualitative approach using interviews with experts and BRT users in the Gauteng Province of South Africa was adopted. Findings indicated that planning should extensively encompass projections of the intended or future performance outcomes. These include institutional arrangements, existing characteristics and impact, service reliability and quality, technical analysis of infrastructural integration, demand, environmental performance metrics and life cycle costs. This inductive research advances the theory of critical factors that could potentially hinder the delivery of PPP-based BRT projects. The findings are envisaged to be beneficial to transport policymakers and stakeholders in the assessment of BRT systems. Failures surrounding the BRT in Gauteng result from an omission of critical factors at the planning stage. This presents a critical lesson for future BRT projects in South Africa and other developing countries, to be meticulous and consider critical factors at the planning stage.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
References
Aaen, S.B., Kerndrup, S. and Lyhne, I. (2016). Beyond public acceptance of energy infrastructure: How citizens make sense and form reactions by enacting networks of entities in infrastructure development. Energy Policy, 96: 576–586. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2016.06.031
Adewumi, E. and Allopi, D. (2013). Rea Vaya: South Africa’s first bus rapid transit system. South African Journal of Science, 109(7/8): 1–3.
African Development Bank Group (AfDB) (2015a). Environmental and social impact assessment report. Available at: https://www.afdb.org/fileadmin/uploads/afdb/Documents/Environmental-and-Social-Assessments/Tanzania_-Dar_es_Salaam_BRT_Project_ESIA_Phase_2_3_Report_-_04_2015.pdf [Accessed on 28 March 2020].
_____. (2015b). AfDB approves the US $141.71-million for the Dar es Salaam Bus Rapid Transit System Project. Available at: https://www.afdb.org/en/news-andevents/afdb-approves-us-141-71-million-for-the-dar-es-salaam-bus-rapidtransit-system-project-14767 [Accessed on 28 March 2020].
Aleshinloye, K. (2015). Financing bus rapid transit in African cities. Available at: http://colabradio.mit.edu/financing-bus-rapid-transit-in-african-cities/ [Accessed on 28 March 2020].
Aleshinloye, K. (2014). What does the future of sustainable transport look like in Lagos? The City Fix, 10 September. Available at: https://thecityfix.com/blog/future-sustainable-transport-lagos-nigeria-eko-rail-brt-cable-car-ferryclimate-kasope-aleshinloye/ [Accessed on 28 March 2020].
Almarri, K. and Boussabaine, H. (2017). Interdependency of the critical success factors and ex-post performance indicators of PPP projects. Built Environment Project and Asset Management, 7(5): 546–556. https://doi.org/10.1108/BEPAM-05-2017-0031
Amadi, C., Carrillo, P. and Tuuli, M. (2014). Stakeholder management in public private partnership projects in Nigeria: Towards a research agenda. In A.B. Raiden and E. Aboagye-Nimo (eds.), Procs 30th Annual ARCOM Conference, 1–3 September 2014. Portsmouth, UK: Association of Researchers in Construction Management (ARCOM), 423–432.
Amara, R.C. and Lipinski, A.J. (1972). Some views on the use of expert judgement. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 3: 279–289. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0040-1625(71)80019-7
Amiegbebhor, D. and Boluwatife, P. (2018). The Lagos bus rapid transit: Review of users’ perception. American Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Research, 2(11): 88–108.
Asian Development Bank (2008). Check list for evaluating HCBRT feasibility studies. Annexe 13. Available at: https://sti-india-uttoolkit.adb.org/mod2/se3/013.html [Accessed on 3 June 2020].
Baghini, M.S., Ismail, A.B., Hafezi, M.H., Seifabad, O.K. and Al-Mansob, R. (2014). Bus rapid transit (BRT) system impacts to environmental quality. Research Journal of Applied Sciences, Engineering and Technology, 7(7): 1344–1350. https://doi.org/10.19026/rjaset.7.400
Berezin, A., Sergi, B.S. and Gorodnova, N. (2018). Efficiency assessment of publicprivate partnership (PPP) projects: The case of Russia. Sustainability, 10(3713): 1–18. https://doi.org/10.3390/su10103713
Braun, V. and Clarke, V. (2012). Thematic analysis. In H. Cooper, P.M. Camic, D.L. Long, A.T. Panter, D. Rindskopf and K.J. Sher (eds), APA Handbook of Research Methods in Psychology, Vol. 2: Research Designs; Quantitative, Qualitative, Neuropsychological and Biological. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, 57–71.
Cascetta, E. and Pagliara, F. (2013). Public engagement for planning and designing transportation systems. Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences, 87: 103– 116. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sbspro.2013.10.597
Casello, J.M., Lewis, G., Yeung, K. and Santiago-Rodríguez, D. (2014). A transit technology selection model. Journal of Public Transportation, 17(4): 50–75. https://doi.org/10.5038/2375-0901.17.4.4
Chengula, D.H. and Kombe, K. (2017). Assessment of the effectiveness of Dar Es Salaam bus rapid transit (DBRT) system in Tanzania. International Journal of Sciences: Basic and Applied Research, 36(8): 10–30.
Cunningham, M. and Wells, M. (2017). Qualitative analysis of 6961 free-text comments from the first national cancer patient experience survey in Scotland. BMJ Open, 7(6): e015726. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2016-015726
Ferranti, E., Andres, L., Denoon-Stevens, S.P. Melgaço, L., Oberling, D. and Quinn, A. (2020) Operational challenges and mega sporting events legacy: The case of BRT Systems in the Global South. Sustainability, 12(4): 1609. https://doi.org/10.3390/su12041609
Galvin, R. (2015). How many interviews are enough? Do qualitative interviews in building energy consumption research produce reliable knowledge? Journal of Building Engineering, 1: 2–12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jobe.2014.12.001
Goondiwala, Z. (2014). Rea Vaya world-class bus rapid transport. The South African Public Sector Innovation Journal, 5(1): 16–19.
Gwilliams, K. (2017). Transport pricing and accessibility. Available at: https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/pricing-and-accessibilitypaper_web.pdf [Accessed on 29 August 2020].
Hensher, D.A. (2007). Sustainable public transport systems: Moving towards a value for money and network-based approach and away from blind commitment. Transport Policy, 14: 98–102. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tranpol.2006.10.004
Huo, Y., Zhao, J., Zhang, J. and Qiu, F. (2015). Development of level-of-service criteria based on a single measure for BRT in China. Journal of Public Transportation, 18(2): 20–33. https://doi.org/10.5038/2375-0901.18.2.2
Ingvardson, J.B. and Nielsen, O.A. (2017). Effects of new bus and rail rapid transit systems: An international review. Transport Reviews, 38(1): 1–21. https://doi.org/10.1080/01441647.2017.1301594
Jennings, G. (2017). Planning for financially sustainable public transport, brief for WWF-SA, low-carbon passenger transport solutions, WWF-SA, Cape Town, South Africa. Available at: http://awsassets.wwf.org.za/downloads/WWF_2017_OPCC_Financially_Sustainable_public_Transport.pdf [Accessed on 28 March 2020].
Kaliba, C., Muya, M. and Mumba, K. (2009). Cost escalation and schedule delays in road construction projects in Zambia. International Journal of Project Management, 27(5): 522–531. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2008.07.003
Kathuria, A., Parida, M., Sekhar, R. and Sharma, A. (2016). A review of bus rapid transit implementation in India. Cogent Engineering, 3(1): 1–23. https://doi.org/10.1080/23311916.2016.1241168
Kermanshahi, S., Shafahi, Y. and Bagherian, M. (2013). Application of a new rapid transit network design model to bus rapid transit network design: Case study Isfahan metropolitan area. Transport, 30(1): 93–102. https://doi.org/10.3846/16484142.2013.816772
Klijn, E.N. and Koppenjan, J. (2016). The impact of contract characteristics on publicprivate partnerships’ performance: Results from a survey among PPP projects in The Netherlands. Public Money and Management, 36(6): 455–462. https://doi.org/10.1080/09540962.2016.1206756
Klopp, J.M., Harber, J. and Quarshie, M. (2019). A review of BRT as public transport reform in African cities. Research synthesis project governance of metropolitan transport background paper. Available at: http://www.vref.se/download/18.45182a5f16a84e95fac6750a/1560236438940/A%20Review%20of%20BRT%20as%20Public%20%20Transport%20Reform%20in%20African%20Cities.pdf [Accessed on 30 June 2020].
Kohlbacher, F. (2006). The use of qualitative content analysis in case study research. Available at: https://www.qualitative-research.net/index.php/fqs/article/view/75/153 [Accessed on 26 February 2021].
Kühn, C. and Visser, J.K. (2014). Managing uncertainty in typical mining project studies. South African Journal of Industrial Engineering, 25(2): 105–120. https://doi.org/10.7166/25-2-800
Lewars, G., McPherson, O., Pelletier, N. and Schwalbenberg, A. (2007). Accommodation of BRT in the Cape Town CBD: The study and planning of a bus rapid transit system as a component of Cape Town’s sustainable transit plan. Available at: https://web.wpi.edu/Pubs/E-project/Available/Eproject-121307-113736/unrestricted/Report.pdf [Accessed on 14 April 2021].
Liu, J., Love, P.E.D., Smith, J. and Regan, M. (2015). A new framework for evaluating public-private partnerships. Paper presented at the 2nd International Conference on Public-Private Partnerships. Austin, Texas, USA, 26–29 May.
Luke, R. and Heyns, G.J. (2020). An analysis of the quality of public transport in Johannesburg, South Africa using an adapted SERVQUAL model. Transportation Research Procedia, 48: 3562–3576. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trpro.2020.08.095
Mabena, S. (2017). BRT, an R15-billion flop. Times LIVE, 10 July. Available at: https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2017-07-10-brt-a-r15-billion-flop/ [Accessed on 28 March 2020].
Mason, M. (2010). Sample size and saturation in PhD studies using qualitative interviews. Forum: Qualitative Social Research, 11(3): 8. https://doi.org/10.17169/fqs-11.3.1428
Menzies, I. and Mandri-Perrott, C. (2010). Private sector participation in urban rail. Gridlines, Note No. 54. Available at: https://ppiaf.org/documents/2062/download [Accessed on 6 June 2020].
Mobereola, D. (2009). Lagos bus rapid transit: Africa’s first BRT scheme. SSATP discussion paper no. 9. Available at: http://www.ssatp.org/sites/ssatp/files/publications/SSATP-DiscussionPapers/DP09-Lagos-BRT.pdf
Moodley, S. (2012). Spatial planning legacy remains. Engineering News, 2 November. Available at: https://www.engineeringnews.co.za/article/apartheid-spatialplanning-legacy-still-remains-moosajee-2012-11-02 [Accessed on 13 April 2021].
Nadeem, M., Azam, M., Asim, M., Al-Rashid, M.A., Puan, O.C. and Campisi, T. (2021). Does bus rapid transit system (BRTS) meet the citizens’ mobility needs? evaluating performance for the case of Multan, Pakistan. Sustainability, 13: 7314. https://doi.org/10.3390/su13137314
Nowell, L.S., Norris, J.M., White, D.E. and Moules, N.J. (2017). Thematic analysis: Striving to meet the trustworthiness criteria. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 16: 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1177/1609406917733847
Ogunlesi, T. (2012). In Lagos, a BRT system struggles to make an impact. Perspectives: Political Analysis and Commentary from Africa, March, 24–26. Available at: https://ke.boell.org/sites/default/files/perspectives_cities_3.12_web.pdf [Accessed on 28 March 2020].
Okoro, C.S., Musonda, I. and Agumba, J.N. (2021). A factor analysis of transportation infrastructure feasibility study factors: A study among built environment professionals in South Africa. In S.M. Ahmed, P. Hampton, S. Azhar and A.D. Saul (eds.), Collaboration and Integration in Construction, Engineering, Management and Technology: Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Construction in the 21st Century, London 2019. Cham: Springer, 75–81.
Orekoya, T. (2010). The bus rapid transit system of Lagos, Nigeria. Available at: https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/dsd/susdevtopics/sdt_pdfs/meetings2010/egm0310/presentation_Orekoya.pdf [Accessed on 9 June 2020].
Otunola, B., Kriticos, S. and Harman, O. (2019). The BRT and the Danfo: A Case Study of Lagos’ Transport Reforms from 1999–2019. London: International Growth Centre (IGC). Available at: https://www.theigc.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/lagos-BRT-case-study.pdf [Accessed on 28 March 2020].
Oviedo, D., Scholl, L., Innao, M. and Pedraza, L. (2019). Do bus rapid transit systems improve accessibility to job opportunities for the poor? The case of Lima, Peru. Sustainability, 11(2795): 1–24. https://doi.org/doi.org/10.18235/0001525
Pezeshknejad, P., Monajem, S. and Mozafari, H. (2020). Evaluating sustainability and land use integration of BRT stations via extended node place model, an application on Tehran’s BRT stations. Journal of Transport Geography, 82: 102626. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2019.102626
Pillay, K. and Seedat, I. (2007). Towards 2020: Public transport strategy and action plan. Paper presented at the 26th Southern African Transport Conference (SATC 2007). Pretoria, South Africa, 9–12 July.
Polit, D.F. and Beck, C.T. (2010). Generalization in quantitative and qualitative research: Myths and strategies. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 47: 1451–1458. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2010.06.004
Raicu, S., Costescu, D., Popa, M. and Rosca, M.A. (2019). Including negative externalities during transport infrastructure construction in the assessment of investment projects. European Transport Research Review, 11: 24. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12544-019-0361-9
Republic of South Africa (2020). Towards sustainable city transport systems, BRT and city bus systems. Available at: https://csp.treasury.gov.za/Resource%20_Centre/Conferences/Documents/Executive%20Leadership%20Programme%20Accelerating%20City%20Transformation/Towards%20sustainable%20city%20transport%20system%20WEB.pdf [Accessed on 13 August 2020].
Rizzo, M. (2019). Dar es Salaam’s new rapid bus system won international acclaim – but it excludes the poor. The Conversation, 22 January. Available at: http://theconversation.com/dar-es-salaams-new-rapid-bus-system-woninternational-acclaim-but-it-excludes-the-poor-109987 [Accessed on 28 March 2020].
Rowley, J. and Slack, F. (2004). Conducting a literature review. Management Research News, 27(6): 31–39. https://doi.org/10.1108/01409170410784185
Salling, K.B. and Leleur, S. (2017). Transport project evaluation: Feasibility risk assessment and scenario forecasting. Journal of Transport, 32(2): 180–191. https://doi.org/10.3846/16484142.2015.1063003
Schalekamp, H. and Klopp, J.M. (2018). Beyond BRT: Innovation in minibus-taxi reform in South African cities. Paper presented at the 37th Annual Southern African Transport Conference (SATC 2018). Pretoria, South Africa, 9–12 July.
Singla, A.K. and Modgil, A. (2020). Review and evaluation of public, private partnership for infrastructural development with special reference to bus terminals. Journal of Critical Reviews, 7(6): 213–219. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2018.03.004
Sreedhara, M., Goins, K.V., Aytur, S.A., Lyn, R., Maddock, J.E., Riessman, R., Schmid, T.L., Wooten, H. and Lemon, S.C. (2016). Qualitative exploration of crosssector perspectives on the contributions of local health departments in landuse and transportation policy. Preventing Chronic Disease, 14: E118. https://doi.org/10.5888/pcd14.170226.
Still, B.G., May, A.D. and Bristow, A.L. (1999). The assessment of transport impacts on land use: Practical uses in strategic planning. Transport Policy, 6(2): 83–98.
Sy, D.T., Likhitruangsilp, V., Onishi, M. and Nguyen, P.T. (2016). Impacts of risk factors on the performance of public-private partnership transportation projects in Vietnam. ASEAN Engineering Journal Part C, 5(1): 49–71.
Tang, L., Shen, G.Q., Skitmore, M. and Wang, H. (2015). Procurement-related critical factors for briefing in public-private partnership projects: Case of Hong Kong. Journal of Management in Engineering, 31(6): 04014096. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)ME.1943-5479.0000352
Tyson, J.E. (2018). Private infrastructure financing in developing countries: Five challenges, five solutions. Working paper 536. Available at: https://cisp.cachefly.net/assets/articles/attachments/75795_12366.pdf [Accessed on 14 August 2020].
Ugo, P.D. (2014). The bus rapid transit system: A service quality dimension of commuter uptake in Cape Town, South Africa. Journal of Transport and Supply Chain Management, 8(1): 1–10. https://doi.org/10.4102/jtscm.v8i1.145
Umeokafor, N., Okoro, C.S., Diugwu, I.A. and Umar, T. (2021). Design for safety in construction in Nigeria: A qualitative inquiry of the critical opportunities. International Journal of Building Pathology and Adaptation, Forthcoming. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJBPA-05-2021-0066
Umlauf, T., Galicia, L.D., Cheu, R.L. and Horak, T. (2016). Ridership estimation procedure for a transit corridor with new bus rapid transit service. Journal of Advanced Transportation, 50: 473–488. https://doi.org/10.1002/atr.1355
United Nations (2020). Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and disability. Available at: https://www.un.org/development/desa/disabilities/about-us/sustainable-development-goals-sdgs-and-disability.html [Accessed on 3 August 2020].
Vaismoradi, M., Jones, J., Turunen, H. and Snelgrove, S. (2016). Theme development in qualitative content analysis and thematic analysis. Journal of Nursing Education and Practice, 6(5): 100–110. https://doi.org/10.5430/jnep.v6n5p100
Van Mead, N. (2019). How an emerging African megacity cut commutes by two hours a day. The Guardian, 8 January. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/jan/08/how-an-emerging-african-megacity-cut-commutesby-two-hours-a-day-dar-es-salaam [Accessed on 28 March 2020].
Venter, I. (2018). No longer flavour of the month: SA rethinks its bus rapid transit systems. Engineering News, 27 July. Available at: http://www.engineeringnews.co.za/article/no-longer-flavour-of-the-month-sa-rethinks-its-bus-rapid-transitsystems-2018-07-27-1 [Accessed on 16 October 2018].
_____. (2009). Challenging times for bus rapid-transit system. Engineering News, 3 April. Available at: https://www.engineeringnews.co.za/article/bustransport-2009-04-03 [Accessed on 13 April 2021].
Victoria Transport Policy Institute (2016). Transportation affordability: Strategies to increase transportation affordability. Available at: https://www.vtpi.org/tdm/tdm106.htm [Accessed on 29 August 2020].
Wood, A. (2017). Advancing development projects through mega-events: The 2010 football World Cup and bus rapid transit in South Africa. Urban Geography, 40(9): 428–444. https://doi.org/10.1080/02723638.2017.1395604
_____. (2015). Competing for knowledge: Leaders and laggards of bus rapid transit in South Africa. Urban Forum, 26: 203–221. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12132-014-9248-y
_____. (2014). Moving policy: Global and local characters circulating bus rapid transit through South African cities. Urban Geography, 35(8): 1238–1254. https://doi.org/10.1080/02723638.2014.954459
World Bank Independent Evaluation Group (n.d.). Implementation completion report (ICR) review. Available at: http://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/551151520551117170/text/Nigeria-NG-LUTP-II-FY10.txt [Accessed on 26 February 2021].
Zohrabi, R. (2013). Mixed methods research: Instruments, validity, reliability and reporting findings. Theory and Practice in Language Studies, 3(2): 254–262. https://doi.org/10.4304/tpls.3.2.254-262