Moral Judgement as a Method in Historiography: An Analysis of al-Biruni’s al-Athar al-Baqiyah ‘an al-Qurun al-Khaliyah
Main Article Content
Abstract
The practice of moral judgement in historiography is a topic in critical philosophy of history. In general, there are two opinions on the practice of moral judgement in history: firstly, those who are against it, such as Croce, Bloch and Butterfield; secondly, those who are in support of it, such as Lord Acton, Ibn Khaldun and al-Biruni. Understanding the practice is crucial in facilitating “intellectual serenity” among historians in deciding on their research method. This article discusses al-Biruni’s position and epistemic justification on the issue of moral judgement in research in history. The analysis of al-Biruni’s perspective, based on his book, al-Athar al-Baqiyah ‘an al-Qurun al-Khaliyah, shows that his epistemic justification on moral judgement in history was influenced by his religious tradition.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
References
Ahmad Kamil Jamilin. 2016. Ilmu jarh wa ta‘dil: Praktikal dalam kehidupan Muslim dan pendakwah. Paper presented at the Home of Hadith: Cinta Hadith Wasilah Cinta Rasul. Kuala Lumpur, 1 May.
Ahmad, R. 2010. Al-Biruni: A great Muslim scientist, philosopher and historian (973– 1050 AD). Pakistan Vision 10(1): 167–179.
Al-Biruni, Mohammad Ibn Ahmad. 1910. Al-Biruni’s India: An account of the religion, philosophy, literature, geography, chronology, astronomy, customs, laws and astrology of India about A.D. 1030, (Vol. I). Translated by E. Sachau. London: Keagan Paul, Trench, Tubner & Co. Ltd.
_______1879. The chronology of ancient nations: An English version of the Arabic text of the Athar al-Bakiya of al-Biruni, or “Vestiges of the Past”, collected and reduced to writing by the author in A.H. 390–1, A.D. 1000. Translated by E. Sachau. London: WH Allen & Co.
Ardi, M.N., Fatimah Abdullah and al-Tamimi, Shihab. 2016. Al-Biruni: A Muslim critical thinker. International Journal of Nusantara Islam 4(1): 1–12. https://doi.org/10.15575/ijni.v4i1.490
Atkinson, R.F. 1978. Knowledge and explanation in history: An introduction to the philosophy of history. Basingstoke, UK: Macmillan Education Ltd. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-15965-9_2
Babbage, S. 1964. The place of moral judgments in the interpretation of history. The Churchman 78: 32–47.
Barton, K.C. 2005. Primary source in history: Breaking through the myths. The Phi Delta Kappan 86(10): 745–753. https://doi.org/10.1177/003172170508601006
Berkhofer, R.F.J. 1995. Beyond the great story: History as text and discourse. Cambridge: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
Boilot, J. 1974. The long odyssey. The UNESCO Courier June: 10–14.
Boucher, D. 1985. Texts in context: Revisionist method for studying the history of ideas. Dordrecht, Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-009-5075-7
Brown, J.A.C. 2009. Did the prophet say it or not? The literal, historical and effective truth of hadiths in early Sunnism. Journal of the American Oriental Society 129(2): 259–285.
Bufano, M. 2008. A reconsideration of the Sunni-Shi’a divide in early Islam. MA diss., Clemson University.
Child, A. 1951. Moral judgement in history. Ethics: An International Journal of Social, Political and Legal Philosophy 61(4): 297–305. https://doi.org/10.1086/290792
Coady, C.A.J. 1973. Testimony and observation. American Philosophical Quarterly 10(2): 149–155. Collingwood, R.G. 1966. The idea of history. London: Oxford University Press.
Evans, R.J. 2000. In defence of history. London: Granta Books.
Falola, T. 2011. History in Sub-Saharan Africa. In The Oxford history of historical writing, volume 4: 1800–1945, eds. S. Macintyre, J. Maiguascha and A. Pok, 597–618. Oxford: Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:osobl/9780199533091.003.0030
Fischel, W.J. 1961. Ibn Khaldun’s use of historical sources. Studia Islamica 14: 109–119. https://doi.org/10.2307/1595187
Fricker, E. 2006. Testimony and epistemic autonomy. In The epistemology of testimony, eds. J. Lackey and E. Sosa, 225–252. Oxford: Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199276011.003.0011
Gafurov, B. 1974. Abu al-Rayhan Mohammed ibn Ahmed al-Biruni: A universal genius who lived in Central Asia a thousand years ago. The UNESCO Courier June: 4–10.
Hallaq, Wael. 1999. The authenticity of prophetic hadith: A pseudo-problem. Studia Islamica 89: 75–90. https://doi.org/10.2307/1596086
Hanaffie Hasin. 2016. Hadis dhaif dalam fadhail amal, targhib, tarhib dan akhlak: Merungkai khilaf dan kekusutan. Paper presented at the Home of Hadith: Cinta Hadith Wasilah Cinta Rasul. Kuala Lumpur, 1 May.
Hooker, B. 2017. What makes a judgement a moral judgement. Journal of Political Theory and Philosophy 1(1): 97–112.
Ibn Khaldun. 1958. The muqaddimah: An introduction to history. Translated by F. Rosenthal. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Kamar Oniah Kamaruzzaman. 2003. Al-Biruni: Father of comparative religion. Intellectual Discourse 2(2): 113–138.
Kamiar, M. (2009). Brilliant Biruni: A life story of Abu Rayhan Mohammad Ibn Ahmad. Lanham, Maryland: The Scarecrow Press, Inc.
Khan, M.A.R. 1951. On the minor tracts of Abu-Raihan Muhammad Ibn Ahmad al-Beruni. In Al-Biruni commemoration volume, A.H. 362–A.H. 1362, eds. M. Ishaque and S.J.V. Courtois, 171–176. Calcutta: Iran Society.
Khan, M.S. 1976. Al-Biruni and the political history of India. Oriens 25/26(1): 86–115. https://doi.org/10.1163/18778372-02502601007
Kosso, P. 2006. Introduction: An epistemology of archaeology. In Archaeological fantasies: How pseudoarchaeology misrepresents the past and misleads the public, ed. G.G. Fagan. Oxford: Routledge.
Krenkow, F. 1951. Beruni and the MS. Sultan Fatih No. 3386. In Al-Biruni commemoration volume, A.H. 362–A.H. 1362, eds. M. Ishaque and S.J.V. Courtois, 195. Calcutta: Iran Society. Lord Acton. 1911. A lecture on the study of history. London: McMillan and Co. Limited.
Mill, J.S. 2001. On liberty (1859). Kitchener, Canada: Batoche Books.
Mohd Akil Muhamed Ali, Mohamad Norazan Ibrahim, Abur Hamdi Usman, Mohd Arif Nazri and Muhd Najib Abdul Kadir. 2015. Al-jarh wa ta’dil: Its significant in the science of hadith. Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences 6(2): 284–292.
Morgan, D.N. and Rasinski, T.V. 2012. The power and potential of primary sources. The Reading Teacher 65(8): 584–594. https://doi.org/10.1002/TRTR.01086
Nasr, Seyyed Hossein. 1978. An introduction to Islamic cosmological doctrines (revised edition). London: Thames and Hudson Ltd.
_______1974. Free-wheeling philosopher: Al-Biruni was a model of the thinker who could harmonize various forms of knowledge without becoming a slave to a particular method or school. The UNESCO Courier June: 38–42.
Notzon, B. and Nesom, G. 2005. The Arabic naming system. Science Editor 28(1): 20–21.
Oldfield, A. 1981. Moral judgments in history. History and Theory 20(3): 260–277. https://doi.org/10.2307/2504557
Phillips, P.T. 2019. Truth, morality and meaning in history. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Plantinga, A. 1986. Epistemic justification. Nous 20(1): 3–18. https://doi.org/10.2307/2215273
Said, Hakim Mohammed. 1974. “Father” of Arabic pharmacy in Medieval Islam. The UNESCO Courier June: 32–37.
Sakmann, P. 1971. The problems of historical method and of philosophy of history in Voltaire (1906). History and Theory 11: 24–59. https://doi.org/10.2307/2504245
Shaw, I.S. 2012. Human rights journalism: Advances in reporting distant humanitarian interventions. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Tucker, A., ed. 2009. Introduction. A companion to the philosophy of history and historiography, 1–6. West-Sussex: Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
Vann, R.T. 2004. Historians and moral evaluations. History and Theory 43(4): 3–30. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2303.2004.00295.x